James McHugh Dies After Being Handcuffed in Midland Texas
James Francis McHugh, 66, was in the process of being taken into custody by the Midland Police Department at 1:25 p.m. on October 13, 2025. Tragically, Mr. McHugh was pronounced deceased a little over an hour later at 2:45 p.m. in the custody of law enforcement personnel after his arrest. Mr. McHugh’s cause of death is pending an autopsy. However, the medical cause of death shown in the custodial death report (CDR) about the decedent indicates the following:
- Cause of death is pending the autopsy; preliminary information suggests a cardiac issue, possibly in conjunction with drug use.
A question in the CDR asks if the deceased was under restraint in the time leading up to the death or the events causing the death, and the Midland Police Department’s response on the CDR shows that Mr. McHugh was under restraint with the use of handcuffs. Other than that, the bulk of the information about how Mr. McHugh’s death occurred is in the summary of the incident, and it conveys the following:
Midland Police Department officers responded to a call regarding an “advise of rights” complaint involving James McHugh, who was attempting to retrieve property from a business. After conducting their investigation, officers arrested Mr. McHugh for Criminal Trespass. He was placed in handcuffs and, due to his age and significant obesity, officers experienced substantial difficulty placing him in the back of a patrol vehicle.
While in the vehicle, Mr. McHugh began having trouble breathing, prompting officers to request Emergency Medical Services. He became unresponsive shortly afterward, was removed from the patrol car, and CPR was initiated. EMS transported Mr. McHugh to the hospital, where he was later pronounced deceased.
The address of the Midland Police Department is 601 N. Loraine Midland, Texas 79701.
Understanding How Fatalities Can Occur After a Person Is Restrained
In some cases, individuals may suffer fatal medical emergencies after being handcuffed or physically restrained by law enforcement. One recognized danger is positional asphyxia, which can occur when a person is placed—or kept—in a position that restricts normal breathing, such as lying face-down with pressure on the back or chest. This type of restraint can make inhalation increasingly difficult and, if not corrected, may lead to respiratory failure.
Additional factors may increase the risk of death during or after restraint. High stress, significant physical struggle, or underlying medical conditions can place severe strain on the heart. The presence of stimulant drugs, including methamphetamine or cocaine, can compound that stress and contribute to a state sometimes described in medical literature as excited delirium, which may lead to cardiac arrest.
Improper restraint techniques, including any neck compression or pressure that restricts airflow or blood flow, also create life-threatening risks. When these events occur during police encounters or jail restraint situations, it is essential to examine whether the force used was appropriate and whether proper monitoring and medical intervention were provided.
Legal Support for Families Impacted by Jail Neglect or Abuse
A jail incarceration does not strip a person of their fundamental rights. When correctional staff fail to provide necessary medical care, fail to protect inmates from harm, or ignore clear warning signs of distress, their inaction can lead to devastating and avoidable outcomes. Facilities have a legal duty to safeguard the individuals in their custody, and when that duty is breached, accountability is essential.
If you believe that neglect, inadequate medical treatment, or other forms of misconduct contributed to your loved one’s death while in jail or law enforcement custody, the Law Offices of Dean Malone, P.C. may be able to assist. Our firm is deeply experienced in handling in-custody death cases, including those involving medical neglect, preventable suicide, and systemic failures within jail environments. We work tirelessly to uncover the truth and advocate for families seeking justice.
Reach out by phone, text message, or through our secure online contact form around the clock to request a free and confidential case review.
smchugh
smchugh