Press Release: Federal Court Denies Jail Medical Provider’s Request to Dismiss Claims About Death of 24-Year-Old Man

Federal Court Denies Jail Medical Provider’s Request to Dismiss Claims About Death of 24-Year-Old Man

For Immediate Release

Tyler, Texas – June 3, 2025

D’Vonte Valentine was arrested by the Tyler Police Department and transported to the Smith County jail. It was immediately clear to everyone that D’Vonte was developmentally disabled and incapable of appropriately communicating his medical needs to Smith County jailers and employees working for Turn Key Health Clinics, LLC (“Turn Key Health”), the jail’s for-profit contract healthcare provider. D’Vonte had congenital adrenal hyperplasia, and he needed specific steroid medications to stay alive. D’Vonte’s family took the needed steroid medications to the Smith County jail. However, instead of either the Smith County jail or Turn Key Health assuring that needed medications were given to D’Vonte, the pill bottles were put into storage with D’Vonte’s other property. Also, no one ordered the needed steroid medications. D’Vonte thus suffered and died as a result of not receiving his medications, when the needed medications were locked away at the jail.

D’Vonte was unfortunately a victim of systemic issues in the Smith County jail. The Smith County jail has been found non-compliant by the Texas Commission on Jail Standards numerous times. Further, an outside consultant conducting an analysis of the jail came to some fairly alarming conclusions regarding a number of aspects of how the jail is run.

Constitutional rights lawyer Dean Malone represents D’Vonte’s mother and filed a federal lawsuit in Tyler. Turn Key Health filed a motion, asking the court to dismiss the case against it. The court, in a 13-page order, denied the motion to dismiss.  Mr. Malone said, “We were glad that the court denied the healthcare provider’s attempt to obtain dismissal of claims against it. There is absolutely no reason that D’Vonte had to suffer and die, when all he needed to live were his usual medications.”

A copy of the order is attached to this post.

Order Denying Motion to Dismiss (SIGNED) file-stamped (Doc 45)

Written By: Dean Malone

Dean Malone

Dean Malone is the founder of Law Offices of Dean Malone, P.C., a jail neglect civil rights law firm. Mr. Malone earned his bachelor's degree at the University of Texas at Dallas, graduating summa cum laude with a 4.0 GPA, and from Baylor University School of Law with a general civil litigation concentration. Mr. Malone served in several staff positions for the Baylor Law Review, including executive editor. Mr. Malone is an experienced trial lawyer, trying a number of cases to jury verdict and also handling arbitrations through final hearing. He heads the jail neglect section of his law firm, in which lawyers litigate cases involving serious injury and death resulting from jail neglect and abuse. Lawyers frequently refer cases to Mr. Malone due to his focus on this very complicated civil rights practice area.

See Full Bio